PCC windmill logoPROTECT
CHERRY COUNTY
Learn more. See the sources.

CHERRY COUNTY, NEBRASKA

Water & monitoring

Two separate records. Dated findings. Clear next steps.

Valentine drinking water

This section concerns the municipal water system, NE3103106. Its wells and sample results are separate from the TK Angus monitoring wells.

Date and sourceWhat it saysWhat remains open
Sept. 17 · City notice [1] Two Well 501 samples averaged 11 mg/L nitrate. The City said it had removed the well from service.Individual laboratory reports and the dates and times the well pumped.
Sept. 30 · DWEE reply [2] Program staff said Well 501 was not removed from service and reported no correspondence requesting removal.How this statement fits with the City notice and the actual operating record.

October 16 update: The City provided the two individual Well 501 laboratory reports, its municipal-well status list, and available production records. The City reports Well 501 was removed from service; DWEE's September 30 response reflected a different status account at that time. Dates and records should be compared before drawing conclusions about the exact last day of pumping. A facility listed as active in the state database does not show whether its pump ran on a particular day. [14] [10]

For current drinking-water instructions: read the City’s notice and contact City Hall at 402-376-2323. This records summary does not establish today’s tap-water condition. [1]

Read the test result in context

The state database lists 11.1 mg/L for sample 1065281, collected August 26, under the analyte name “NITRATE-NITRITE.” The City notice describes an 11 mg/L nitrate average from August 26 and September 9 samples. Preserve those different labels and measures; one result is not the two-sample average. [1] [11]

DWEE’s September 30 response directs readers to Drinking Water Watch for results and to the state health laboratory for the underlying laboratory reports. [2]

Records and verification still needed

The City supplied the August 26 and September 9 individual lab reports: 11.1 mg/L and 10.5 mg/L nitrate/nitrite, an average of 10.8 mg/L, reported as 11 mg/L in its notice. The next work is to reconcile the date-specific pump/weekly-meter records, Well 501 restart testing if any, and subsequent operating instructions. Read the City's October 16 response excerpts. [14]

What this does not show

The records reviewed do not identify the source of the nitrate, establish the concentration at every tap, or resolve the conflicting service-status statements.

PFAS and wellhead records

DWEE says its voluntary initial PFAS monitoring project continues through April 2027 and that it will publish the dataset when complete. That September DWEE response supplied no Valentine-specific PFAS concentration, but the City later provided laboratory reports, sampling records and correspondence concerning its wells. The City has flagged an apparent error in a 2026 PFAS assessment table; that disputed entry should not be presented as a verified measurement. A planning reference or an unpublished result is not a finding of contamination or safety. [14] [2]

DWEE directed PCC to the public Wellhead layer in NebraskaMap. It also withheld an unredacted protection-area map and GIS file in RM-2026-749; RM-2026-747 additionally lists a time-of-travel delineation. The difference between the public layer and withheld files remains a question for the agency. [2] [3]

VALENTINE MUNICIPAL WATER · NOVEMBER 13, 2026

New test wells: bids, proposed sites and next steps

The Valentine City Council approved a Sargent Irrigation bid on November 12, 2026, according to News Channel Nebraska's November 13 report. The City supplied the November 4 bid tabulation and proposed-site maps in response to PCC on November 13. The bid concerns drilling, testing and sampling for up to four test wells, not four completed production wells. [15] [16] [18]

Bid basis: up to four test wellsSargent IrrigationDowney Drilling
Single mobilization$150,835$251,560
Two mobilizations$154,835$271,560

These are itemized bid totals, not final costs, proof of completed work, or authorization to put any new well into the drinking-water system. The bid includes test-hole drilling, logging, well construction and development, test pumping, 13-parameter samples and full-well-scan samples. [16] [17]

Six locations under consideration

The three Olsson map figures, dated November 5, label six candidate sites as #1, #1A, #1B, #2, #3 and #4. The mapped areas include locations near Valentine Municipal Airport and near the Mill Pond/reservoir area. These are proposals; the supplied maps do not establish a final site selection or permitting approval. News coverage says state and FAA review may be needed. [16] [18]

View the November 4 bid tabulation and Olsson maps (4-page PDF) · View Sargent's itemized bid schedules (2-page PDF).

What's confirmed, and what remains open

Preliminary Engineering Report

City Manager Shane Siewert said November 13 that Olsson's report was not complete. An unfinished report should not be described as a final engineering recommendation.

Official minutes

He said the November 12 Council minutes had not yet been written. The bid documents and contemporaneous news report are available; adopted minutes remain an outstanding record.

Well inspections and tests

The City said it had no new responsive state well-site inspection or testing-protocol records since its prior response. Site approvals, drilled-well logs, sample results and production decisions have not been established by this new document release.

Read selected excerpts of the City's November 13 records response. [15]

Financing and PFAS settlement funds are separate records

In its October 16 response, the City described a potential $1.9 million 2027 State Revolving Fund planning package: $1,425,000 identified for possible principal forgiveness and $475,000 in additional financing. The City explicitly stated it had not submitted an application or entered an assistance agreement for that potential funding. Planning-list amounts are not awarded grants. [14]

The City also identified $356,474.67 in three 2025 PFAS-litigation receipts recorded in its Water Department fund. Its records did not identify the final gross recovery, complete fee breakdown, or specific uses of those proceeds. That settlement accounting should not be conflated with the proposed new-well bid or potential financing. [14]

Evidence boundary: Valentine's municipal-water sampling and well-replacement planning are separate from the TK Angus groundwater-monitoring permit. The City records do not identify TK Angus as the cause of Valentine's nitrate or PFAS issues.

TK Angus: follow the monitoring plan

The plan is dated August 17 and marked received August 19, 2026. It describes the following work. A plan states what is to be done; field reports show what was done. [4]

Plan requirementWhere to check
One upgradient well (MW-1), two downgradient wells (MW-2 and MW-3)Section 3.1; PDF page 4
Drilled locations, well registrations, and casing elevations with the first sampling eventSection 3.2; PDF page 5
Sampling in spring and fallSection 4.2; PDF page 6
Chloride, ammonium, and nitrateTable 1; PDF page 7
A duplicate sample and a field blank for quality checksSection 4.6; PDF page 8
A report within 45 days after each sampling eventSection 6; PDF page 9

Read the full 19-page plan. “PDF page” counts the cover and contents pages.

November 2 update: a later monitoring letter

PCC’s October 29 docket review identified an October 21 groundwater-monitoring letter. Agency review, well-construction and development records, and baseline sampling are the next items to track. Read the dated update and its verification limits.

The next records to check

Installed wells

Locations, drilling logs, screen depths, registrations, and measured water levels.

First and repeat tests

Dated results, quality-control results, and the conditions at each sampling event.

Agency review

DWEE’s review of each report and any follow-up, correction, or enforcement record.

Before use

Construction certification and DWEE’s written approval for use of the waste-control facilities. [5]

No installed-well report or sample-result report is included in the source set reviewed for this edition. That is a limit of this review, not proof that no such report exists. Check the live agency docket for later filings.

Details that need clarification

Section 2.2 describes “holding ponds” and uses Township 23N / Range 27N. The permit describes underfloor deep-pit barns in Township 33N / Range 27W. The plan maps show T33N R27W. These are documented mismatches; their technical significance needs an agency or professional explanation. [4] [5]

The plan uses regional information to propose groundwater flow toward the north-northwest and estimates water depth at 40-60 feet. Installed-well measurements are needed to confirm site conditions. The timing of the first sample relative to construction and use also needs a dated record. [4]